6 Into the Swing Era

Announcements:

Last time we talked about Louis Armstrong. One thing he did specifically was do Scat Soloing.

Another big icon in jazz trumpet specifically was Bix Beiderbecke, considered the other big trumpetist like Louis Armstrong, but contrasted Louis's big and vibrant sounds with more somber sounds.

A big saxophonist was Freddie Trumbauer, who played a lot with Bix Beiderbecke as described below:

Pasted image 20250123092142.png

Another white famous trumpet Soloist. Comparing with Louis Armstrong, he is more mellow in his tone and chill. He doesn't play the high notes and more technical things like Louis.

See him play with Freddie Trumbauer in Singin the Blues, and Eddie Lang on guitar:

  • Notice how somber and mellow it is in comparison to Louis Armstrong and His Hot Five's (ex: the West End Blues, where the chord structure is standard Jazz Form of 12-bar blues).
  • We see again the endings of banjo in this piece (as it'll leave jazz eventually).
  • There is no bass player, replaced by the guitarist here.
  • The drums are likely not heard since it was recorded using sensitive hardware.

He is often considered less virtuostic than Louis, with:

  • more melodic phrases
  • but more expression with dynamics
  • considered the more restrained/controlled in his sound
  • cooler, drier tone. He plays with the band more.
Classical Origins

Beiderbecke came from a more classical background, so he uses a lot of the whole tone scale in his compositions, such as In a Mist. This would inspire a lot of the common jazz scales we use today!

Hot vs. Cool

You can see there's a hot vs. cool argument happening here, where hot is Louis Armstrong while cool is Bix Beiderbecke.

Note

You can literally think of hot as being spicy, sharp, etc. while cool is more mellow, refreshing, calming.

Notice this in Armstrong's When You're Smiling piece, where:

  • It's a slower, cooler piece, in contrast to a lot of his other pieces. He gets to scat a bit more here, but even here when he gets to his solo in the middle we see more of his register and range. It's easy to see how it contrasts with the slower nature of the piece.
  • Notice the vibrato on the high notes too.
    Let's listen, in contrast, to Beiderbeck's Riverboat Shuffle, where:
  • It's more up-tempo, like an Armstrong piece.
  • But there more mixed soloing (again some of that organized chaos in comping from Ragtime)
  • Even the solos are more tame. They have less register range than say Armstrong's.
  • If people do solo, it's usually Trading 4's or something smaller.

1930s Jazz "Swing Era"

This becomes the time where:

There's more individual solos, where there's a lot more Call And Response in these solos. This is commonly done in trading, such as we see in Trading 4's. As a result, we see a lot more virtuosity like we saw in Louis Armstrong's piece, leading into the Bebop era that we'll see in the 40s.

Started in 1926, but played all the way into the 70's. Duke Ellington would bring his own style into his pieces.

Pasted image 20250130084807.png

Duke Ellington was the main composer. Some of the notable names in his band were:

Songs:

  • East St. Louis Toodle-Oo (1927)
    • You can hear this going away from the 1920s era of 4 Leaving Ragtime, Early Jazz
    • You can hear Bubbler Miley on the trumpet, trying to get help from the rhythm section to create a "scary" sound.
    • This song is so early (1927) that they still have banjo!
    • You can hear the growling sound from the trumpet mute here!
    • It's cool to see the reeds section of the Big Band with clarinets, which creates layers (the trumpets start layering too).
  • Black and Tan Fantasy (1927)
    • Creates a jungle feel
    • Native drums, and the rhythm section is making it feel like a jungle
    • The trumpet (again Bubbler Miley) uses the mute to recreate and add color of say jungle animals.
    • Duke Ellington gets to do some Stride (Piano) in his solo.
    • At the end we get funeral music (chopin), so he's quoting him (again, it's his style).
  • Duke Ellington's Mood Indigo (1930):
    • It's was said that he (along with the band) came up with this in 20 minutes right before the broadcast.
    • There's smoother flow of the rhythm
    • Notice the inclusion of the string bass now, keeping the rhythm and the walking tempo.
    • He really liked inverting the roles of the upper/lower register instruments. Here the clarinet is playing low notes, the bones playing the high notes, and the trumpet is playing in the middle with a mute.
    • A new one from (1952) is this arrangement
      • Note the odd orchestration w/ bass clarinet and 2 muted bones.
      • All these instruments perfectly played as a trio
      • Again AABA Jazz Form.
  • Concerto for Cootie (1940)
    • Outline:
      • 12 bar intro
      • 1st Chorus: Trumpet + Sax
      • 2nd Chorus: Sax + Cootie Williams
      • 3rd Chorus: Bones/Clarinet
    • Notice how much the sax + trumpet parts stays as the chorus, but they are always changing. Especially with Cootie Williams they start to comp for each other with Call And Response.
    • Again the AABA form.
    • You hear the Jungle style come back in.
    • Here's it cool, not getting as high than in Jubilee.
    • The bass is doing a Square Rhythm when it joins the saxes in the harmonic lines.
  • Cottontail (1940):
    • Features Tenor Sax player Ben Webster
    • Form:
      • AAB(4 measure interlude)
      • Ben Webster solo
      • Again Ben Webster solo
      • Brass + piano
      • Sax
      • Brass + Sax
    • Notice at the end they do the interlude at the very end (but just more modified)
    • The bass and sax section get to do Call And Response.
    • Notice that with 6 Into the Swing Era and onward, the Jazz Form becomes so important! Keep it in mind.
  • Transbluency (1946)
    • One of the first times we get to see a vocalist (almost sounds like a theramin
    • Sounds very orchestral sounding and mysterious, especially in the form is a less swung style of jazz.
  • Take the A Train (1941) (original)
    • Has an AABA Jazz Form.
    • Trumpet solo (played by Cootie Williams?)
      • It’s cool cause the trumpet gets to Trading 4's with the whole rest of the band.
      • The trumpet play loves to play the B sections with different scales that clog against the chord structures.
    • See a more modern playing in 1962
      • The Trading 4's part was on a different key to augment it.